Two Fundamentally Different Models
Before comparing features, you need to understand that Amazon and Shopify are not alternatives in the way Nike and Adidas are alternatives. They solve different problems.
Amazon is a marketplace. You list your products alongside millions of other sellers. Customers come to Amazon to buy things -- they search, compare, and purchase. You tap into Amazon's existing traffic, but you play by Amazon's rules. You share the product page with other sellers. You compete for the Buy Box. You have limited control over branding.
Shopify is a storefront builder. You create your own online store on your own domain. Customers come to your store because you brought them there -- through ads, SEO, social media, or word of mouth. You control everything: design, pricing, customer experience, data. But you start with zero traffic.
This distinction matters more than any individual feature comparison. Amazon gives you customers but takes control. Shopify gives you control but demands that you find customers yourself.
---
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Factor | Amazon FBA | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Traffic source | Built-in (300M+ active customers) | You bring your own (ads, SEO, social) |
| Customer trust | Very high (Amazon brand) | Depends on your brand reputation |
| Referral / transaction fees | 8 - 15% per sale (category-dependent) | 0% on Shopify Payments (or 0.5 - 2% third-party) |
| Monthly subscription | EUR 39/month (Professional plan) | USD 39/month (Basic plan) |
| Fulfilment fees | FBA fees per unit (pick, pack, ship) | You handle it (or use a 3PL) |
| Branding control | Limited (shared listings, Amazon UI) | Full (your design, your domain) |
| Customer data ownership | No (Amazon owns the relationship) | Yes (email, address, purchase history) |
| Competition on listing | Direct (multiple sellers per ASIN) | None (your store, your products) |
| Return handling | Amazon handles returns (FBA) | You handle returns |
| Repricing required | Yes (Buy Box competition) | No (you set your own prices) |
| Time to first sale | Days to weeks | Weeks to months (traffic dependent) |
| Long-term scalability | High but platform-dependent | High and fully independent |
---
When Amazon FBA Is the Better Choice
You sell products with existing demand
If customers are already searching for your product on Amazon -- say, phone cases, yoga mats, or kitchen scales -- Amazon FBA puts your product in front of them immediately. You do not need to convince people to buy this type of product. You only need to convince them to buy yours. Amazon's search engine does the heavy lifting of matching buyers with products.
You have no marketing budget for customer acquisition
Driving traffic to a Shopify store costs money. Facebook ads, Google Ads, influencer partnerships, SEO content -- all of these require upfront investment with delayed returns. On Amazon, the traffic is already there. You pay Amazon's fees instead of advertising fees, but the path from listing to sale is shorter.
You want logistics handled for you
FBA (Fulfilment by Amazon) means Amazon stores your inventory, picks, packs, and ships orders, handles customer service for those orders, and processes returns. For a solo entrepreneur or a small team, this removes an enormous operational burden. You ship your products to Amazon's warehouse and focus on sourcing and marketing.
You are doing arbitrage or wholesale
If your business model is reselling existing branded products -- buying at wholesale prices and selling at retail -- Amazon is usually the primary channel. These products already have Amazon listings with reviews and search demand. You add your offer to the existing listing and compete for the Buy Box. Shopify does not work well for arbitrage because customers search for these products on Amazon, not on unknown stores.
---
When Shopify Is the Better Choice
You are building a brand from scratch
If you have your own product with your own branding, Shopify gives you complete control over how that brand is presented. Your store design, your product photography, your storytelling -- everything reflects your vision, not Amazon's template. Customers associate the purchase experience with your brand, not with Amazon.
You want to own the customer relationship
On Amazon, the customer belongs to Amazon. You cannot email them, you cannot retarget them, you do not even get their full address in most cases. On Shopify, every customer is yours. You collect email addresses, build a mailing list, run retargeting campaigns, and create a direct relationship that outlasts any single transaction.
You sell subscription or consumable products
Shopify has excellent native support for subscription models through apps like Recharge or Loop. If your product is consumed and reordered regularly -- supplements, coffee, skincare -- a Shopify store with subscription billing creates predictable recurring revenue. Amazon's Subscribe & Save exists but gives you far less control over pricing, frequency, and the customer experience.
You want full pricing control
On Shopify, you set your price and that is the price. No other seller undercuts you on your own store. No algorithm decides whether your price is "competitive enough" to show the Buy button. No Buy Box to win or lose. You decide your margin and communicate your value directly to the customer.
---
Using Both Together: The Strongest Strategy in 2026
The most successful e-commerce businesses in 2026 do not choose between Amazon and Shopify. They use both.
Amazon as a discovery and sales channel. Millions of customers search Amazon daily. Your products appear in search results, gain reviews, and generate sales volume. Amazon handles fulfilment through FBA. You use Amazon's marketplace reach to generate revenue and build product credibility.
Shopify as your brand home base. Your Shopify store is where your brand lives. You control the customer experience, build an email list, run promotions on your terms, and keep the full margin on every sale. Customers who discover you on Amazon can find your Shopify store through your brand name and become direct customers.
How this works in practice:
- Launch your product on Amazon to validate demand and collect reviews
- Once you have traction, build a Shopify store with your brand identity
- Use Amazon sales data to inform which products to feature on Shopify
- Drive repeat customers to Shopify through email marketing and social media
- Keep Amazon as a high-volume sales channel while building direct relationships through Shopify
This dual-channel approach gives you the best of both worlds: Amazon's traffic and Shopify's control.
> Think strategically: Many sellers start on Amazon, build revenue, and use those profits to fund a Shopify store. There is no rule that says you must choose one platform forever.
---
Why Amazon Sellers Need Repricing (and Shopify Sellers Do Not)
This is the one factor that most Amazon-vs-Shopify comparisons skip, and it might be the most important one for your daily operations.
On Shopify, you set your price. Period. If you sell a candle for USD 24.99, every customer who visits your store sees USD 24.99. No other seller can undercut you on your own product page. Your pricing strategy is entirely in your hands.
On Amazon, pricing is a competition. Multiple sellers can list the same product (the same ASIN), and Amazon's algorithm decides who gets the Buy Box -- the "Add to Cart" button that captures roughly 83% of all Amazon sales. Price is one of the biggest factors in that decision. If your competitor drops their price by EUR 0.50, you may lose the Buy Box and your sales plummet, even if your listing has better reviews.
This is why repricing software exists. A repricer monitors your competitors' prices in real time and adjusts your price automatically to stay competitive. It protects your Buy Box share without requiring you to check prices manually dozens of times a day.
Without a repricer, you are either:
- Priced too high and losing the Buy Box to competitors
- Priced too low and leaving money on the table
- Checking prices manually and wasting hours every day
With a repricer, your prices adjust dynamically based on rules you define: minimum margin, maximum price, competitor targeting, time-of-day strategies. The repricer does the work. You focus on growing your business.
> If you sell on Amazon: Repricing is not optional. It is the mechanism that turns your listings into sales. Try arbytrage.io free for 14 days -- EUR 40/month, full Pan-EU support.
For a detailed breakdown of all Amazon seller fees, see our fee guide.
---
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sell on Amazon and Shopify at the same time?
Yes, and many successful sellers do exactly that. You can even use Shopify's Amazon sales channel integration to manage inventory across both platforms. The key is to maintain consistent pricing (Amazon's price parity policy requires your Amazon price to not be higher than your price on other channels) and to keep inventory levels synchronised.
Which platform has lower fees?
It depends on your product. Shopify charges a flat monthly fee plus payment processing (around 2.9% + USD 0.30 per transaction on the Basic plan with Shopify Payments). Amazon charges a monthly fee plus referral fees (8-15%) plus FBA fees if you use fulfilment. For low-price items, Amazon fees can eat 30-40% of your revenue. For high-price items with good margins, the percentage impact is smaller. Run the numbers for your specific product before deciding.
Do I need a brand to sell on Shopify?
No, but it helps enormously. You can technically sell any product on a Shopify store, but without a recognisable brand, driving traffic is expensive and conversion rates are low. Customers trust Shopify stores that look professional and have a clear brand identity. If you are doing arbitrage or wholesale, Amazon is almost always the better starting point.
How much does it cost to start on each platform?
Amazon Professional plan: EUR 39/month plus inventory costs. You can start selling within days if you have products ready. Shopify Basic: USD 39/month plus a domain (around USD 14/year) plus a theme (free or USD 150-350 one-time). You also need to budget for marketing to drive traffic -- realistically USD 500-2,000/month for paid ads when starting out.
Which platform is better for beginners?
Amazon has a lower barrier to first sales because traffic is built in. You list a product, optimise the listing, and customers find you through Amazon's search. Shopify requires more upfront work -- building a store, creating content, running ads -- before you see your first sale. If you are starting with limited experience and budget, Amazon FBA is typically the faster path to revenue. You can always add Shopify later as your business grows.
For a complete guide to launching on Amazon, read our How to Start Amazon FBA in Europe article. If you want to understand all the costs involved, check our Amazon Seller Fees breakdown.
---
> Bottom line: Amazon and Shopify serve different purposes. Amazon gives you access to millions of buyers. Shopify gives you ownership of your brand. The smartest sellers use both -- and they use a repricer to make sure every Amazon sale counts. arbytrage.io -- EUR 40/month, Pan-EU repricing